THE ADVENTURE COLLECTIVE® · Independent discovery and booking for outdoor travel
Explore/Local Experts/Experience Finger Lakes/Gola Osteria Italian Wine Face-Off Dinner in Ithaca — Sommelier Showdown & 4-Course Pairings
others

Gola Osteria Italian Wine Face-Off Dinner in Ithaca — Sommelier Showdown & 4-Course Pairings

Two sommelier teams, four Italian courses by Chef Sam Epps, and a playful audience vote—Gola Osteria’s Wine Face-Off turns dinner into a tasting laboratory. Come for the truffle pumpkin cappellacci; stay for the rivalry.

Book with Experience Finger Lakes

Choose a date and book.

Open booking in a new tab
If the calendar does not load, open secure booking in a new tab

Field Guide

A closer look at the experience.

Two sommelier teams, four Italian courses by Chef Sam Epps, and a playful audience vote—Gola Osteria’s Wine Face-Off turns dinner into a tasting laboratory. Come for the truffle pumpkin cappellacci; stay for the rivalry.

Written by The Adventure Collective

On a brisk December evening at Gola Osteria in Ithaca, New York, four courses and two rival wine lists turn a dinner into an event. Gola Osteria Italian Wine Face-Off Dinner brings together Chef Sam Epps’s inspired Italian cooking with a head-to-head tasting from sommelier Laura Winter Falk and wine importer Andrew Salamida. The restaurant sits at 115 S Quarry St in the heart of Ithaca; guests meet at La Tourelle Hotel and Spa to begin an evening that is as much about conversation as it is about flavor.

The format is theatrical but approachable: a sparkling wine reception opens the night with aranci and antipasti, then four plated courses—pumpkin cappellacci with black truffle and brown butter; a Secondi of grilled quail or a portabello stuffed with wild mushrooms for vegetarians; and a lemon olive oil cake with blood orange and cranberry—each matched by two competing Italian selections. Laura and Andrew present their picks, explain the structure of the wines, and invite diners to rate each pairing. Scores are tallied and one sommelier walks away with bragging rights, a playful prize that keeps the mood lively.

What makes this dinner unique in Ithaca is its blend of local hospitality and focused wine education. Gola Osteria showcases regionally minded service in a dining room designed for conversation; the event format transforms a meal into an informal class on how acidity, tannin, and regional tradition interact with familiar Italian flavors. The setting—Gola Osteria’s intimate tables and the casual elegance of La Tourelle Hotel and Spa—keeps the emphasis on food and discovery rather than formality.

Practical details matter: this is a 21+ event with a set price of $120 per person plus tax and gratuity, and pre-registration is required. Vegetarians have a clear option at the Secondi course but guests should note dietary needs in advance. Expect about 2.5 hours for the full experience; arrive early to enjoy the sparkling reception in full.

This wine face-off is ideal for those who travel for taste—food lovers looking for a guided tasting, visitors to Ithaca wanting a memorable evening out, or locals curious to see two distinct wine professionals make their case. It’s a social, sensory-focused night that leaves you with clearer tasting notes, a few new favorite bottles, and a story to tell on your way back to whatever Ithaca lodging you’ve chosen.

Arrive at Gola Osteria at 5:30 to enjoy the sparkling wine and antipasti reception full; that check-in detail shows how the evening is paced for conversation and tasting. For visitors to the Finger Lakes, this dinner is a refined option after hikes or winery tours—an opportunity to compare pairing methods and leave with a clearer palate and new bottles to buy.

Plan your trip

Things to know before you go.

Minimal physical exertion; appropriate for most adults who can sit through a multi-course meal.

Arrive early

Plan to arrive at 5:30 so you don’t miss the sparkling wine and antipasti reception—this opening sets the pace for the night.

Bring ID

This is a 21+ event; carry government-issued ID to gain entry.

Note dietary needs

A vegetarian Secondi option is available—mark dietary restrictions on your booking so the kitchen can prepare.

Rate thoughtfully

Bring a pen or use your phone to record impressions—the scoring is part of the fun and helps you track favorites.

What to bring

  • Photo-ready clothing — Smart-casual attire helps you feel comfortable in an intimate dining room and photograph dishes.
  • Government ID (essential) — Required for entry to this 21+ event.
  • Payment method (card or cash) (essential) — Cover the $120 per person fee plus tax and gratuity and any extras.
  • Notebook or tasting app — Handy for jotting tasting notes and voting on pairings.

Beyond the itinerary

A little local perspective.

Ithaca’s dining scene has grown alongside the Finger Lakes wine industry and a local farm-to-table movement, shaping the region’s culinary identity.

Places to keep an eye out for

  • Ask the staff about the featured spumante rosato during the reception for a standout pairing note
  • Request a window table at Gola Osteria to watch street activity and enjoy natural light during early service

Wildlife notes

  • white-tailed deer
  • red-tailed hawk

Gola Osteria and local operators emphasize seasonal ingredients and relationships with nearby producers; diners can support reduced food miles by choosing regionally sourced pairings.

Your questions, answered.

Is this event open to minors?

No. Attendees must be 21 or older; bring valid ID.

How long does the dinner last?

Plan for roughly 2.5 hours to enjoy the reception and four-course program.

What is the cost and what’s included?

The price is $120 per person plus tax and gratuity and includes the four-course meal and the paired wines presented during the event.

Do you offer vegetarian options?

Yes. A vegetarian Secondi (portabello stuffed with wild mushrooms) is available—note your preference when booking.

Do I need to pre-register?

Yes. Pre-registration is necessary to attend and space can be limited.

Where do I check in?

Arrive at Gola Osteria and check in at the reception; the meeting point is La Tourelle Hotel and Spa and the event recommends arriving at 5:30.

Keep the adventure going

More experiences with Experience Finger Lakes

Verified experiences and guided adventures in the surrounding area.