Fishing at the Fryingpan River’s “Toilet Bowl”: A Premier Angling Experience

For anglers, the Fryingpan River’s “Toilet Bowl” is the stuff of legends. Located just below the Ruedi Reservoir Dam near Basalt, Colorado, this unique stretch of water is renowned for its massive trout, crystal-clear currents, and year-round fishing opportunities. The sight of trophy-sized rainbow and brown trout lurking in the deep, swirling pool is enough to get any fly fisher’s heart racing.

The nickname “Toilet Bowl” comes from the powerful, swirling eddies created by the dam’s outflow, which oxygenate the water and keep it at a cool, trout-friendly temperature. This creates the perfect environment for fish to thrive, making it one of the best tailwater fisheries in the world. But fishing here isn’t just about catching monster trout—it’s about the thrill of the pursuit, the beauty of the Fryingpan Valley, and the camaraderie of anglers sharing the experience.

As you cast your line into the swirling waters, patience is key. The trout here are smart, well-fed, and selective, so presenting the perfect fly is half the battle. Whether you’re nymphing deep with a Mysis shrimp pattern or trying your luck with a small dry fly, the anticipation builds with every cast. When the strike comes, it’s electric—a reminder of why the Toilet Bowl has such a magnetic pull for fly fishers worldwide.

Surrounded by the dramatic scenery of the Fryingpan Valley, with the sound of rushing water and the occasional eagle soaring overhead, fishing at the Toilet Bowl is an experience that goes beyond the catch. It’s a connection to one of Colorado’s most iconic rivers, a celebration of angling, and a story you’ll be telling for years to come.

Adventure Guide: Fishing at the Fryingpan River’s Toilet Bowl

Overview

The “Toilet Bowl” is a legendary fishing spot on the Fryingpan River, located directly below the Ruedi Dam. Known for its large trout and challenging conditions, this tailwater section is a bucket-list destination for serious anglers.

Key Details

• Location: Below Ruedi Reservoir Dam, near Basalt, Colorado.
• Species: Rainbow trout, brown trout.
• Size Potential: Trophy-sized trout, often exceeding 10 pounds.
• Season: Year-round, with consistent flows and temperatures due to the dam’s regulation.

What to Know Before You Go

• Access:
  • Park at the dam’s base and follow the short trail to the river.
  • Arrive early, as this spot is popular and can become crowded.
• Best Flies:
  • Nymphs: Mysis Shrimp, Zebra Midge, RS2, Pheasant Tail.
  • Dry Flies: Blue Wing Olive (BWO), Parachute Adams.
  • Streamers: Woolly Bugger, Zonker (for larger, aggressive trout).
• Regulations:
  • Strict catch-and-release policies.
  • Barbless hooks are recommended for safe handling of large fish.

Tips for Fishing the Toilet Bowl

1. Master the Drift: The swirling waters demand precise line control. Use weighted flies or split shot to get your nymphs deep where the fish feed.
2. Stay Stealthy: These trout are heavily pressured—keep your profile low and avoid loud movements near the water’s edge.
3. Time It Right: Mornings and evenings often bring better action, especially during hatches.
4. Prepare for Crowds: The popularity of the Toilet Bowl means sharing the water with other anglers—practice good etiquette and rotate spots.

Directions

From Aspen, drive 27 miles west on CO-82 to Basalt. Turn onto Fryingpan Road and follow it 14 miles to the Ruedi Reservoir Dam. Parking is available near the base of the dam.

Gear Recommendations

• Rod: 9-foot, 5- or 6-weight fly rod for precise casts and control over larger fish.
• Reel: A smooth drag system to handle the powerful runs of trophy trout.
• Tippet: 4x to 6x fluorocarbon for stealthy presentations in clear water.
• Waders and Boots: Necessary for comfortable access, especially in colder months.

Pro Tips

• Mysis Magic: The Mysis shrimp, flushed from the reservoir, is a consistent and effective fly choice—bring plenty in different sizes.
• Weather Awareness: The area can get windy, especially near the dam. Bring layers to stay warm.
• Plan for the Day: After a morning session, enjoy lunch in Basalt or explore other stretches of the Fryingpan River.
• Snap a Photo: If you land a trophy fish, take a quick photo before carefully releasing it back to the water.

Safety and Sustainability

• Handle Fish Gently: Use wet hands when handling trout, and keep them in the water as much as possible to reduce stress.
• Watch Your Step: The rocks near the river can be slippery—use caution when wading or moving along the bank.
• Leave No Trace: Pack out all trash, including tippet scraps and fly packaging, to keep this iconic spot pristine.

Fishing the Fryingpan River’s Toilet Bowl is more than just a day on the water—it’s an adventure into one of Colorado’s most celebrated angling destinations. From the thrill of the catch to the serenity of the surroundings, every moment here feels like a triumph. Whether you’re chasing trophy trout or simply savoring the beauty of the Fryingpan, this spot is a true gem for fly fishing enthusiasts.